I was not expecting to have such a publicity and being referenced by Jerry on his fb threads.
So I'll give you some examples of battles that I came to witness recently, and the different atmospheres and attitudes that we can get inspired from :
First, street dance :
The Bust A Move competition held in Montreal last May is described as the biggest urban dances competition in Canada. Dancers came from all over Canada, the US, Japan, France, etc. There was hip hop, house, waacking, locking, popping, bboying...
The hip hop finals :
Jr Boog VS Leah McFly : Check out their attitudes when one is dancing, how each of them provoke the other, what kind of movements they use to provoke, the mimicry, but also the way they congratulate each other after the final judgement
The Locking semi-finals (top 6) :
Salah VS Hurrikane (in a funky outfit). I'm posting this video because Salah (in black) was one of my favorite dancers. This video is also interesting to observe the interaction between them, and how being the first or the second to go can be decisive. The obvious reason being that Hurrikane can and will take each Salah's "flash" move to turn it against him and win after a first tie. And big hug happening at 5:24 and again at 5:29. 2 hugs are better than one, right :-)
The mimicry :
Check Salah at 1:04
Check Hurrikane at 1:48
Check Salah at 3:47, ... just because ! :-)
Check Salah at 3:44
Check Hurrikane at 4:12-4:25
The Waacking !!!
Their attitudes !! OMG !! The battle is starting BEFORE the battle, like the Sumo, by the way they enter the stage, get prepared, introduce themselves, you already know who's gonna win (or almost ..:-))
And finally, the swing dance one-to-one battles.
I think everybody will agree that the best battles happen at Showdown
Of course, first of all, ULHS, the Decavitas VS Villafane and Davis. There, you can feel the emulation !!
In 2009, the finals between DaxAnnie VS JoannaChance : the energy is what made this battle
In 2010, again, ULHS solo charleston finals. BBonsey clearly knows the battle culture. When Chance was taking the advantage at 1:10, Bobby exploded it at 1:29.
I don't feel that the "battle" really happens when the couples dance at the same time :
Savoy Swing Jam 2011
And at last, the object of disapproval : Camp Jitterbug Lindy Couples Finals
I repeat, I was also frustrated by the way it happened, BUT some were capable of winning anyway and catch the judges' attention.
This brings to another debate, that is what should or could be more valued in a strictly competition. Is it the flashy dance, the well executed choreographed sequences, or the spontaneity, the musicality, the unexpected ...
So, what's your opinion ?
I personally don't feel AT ALL comfortable with the battle format, it's difficult, I don't speak loud and don't dance loud. But I want to try. I want to challenge you and challenge my comfort zone. And I also want to get closer to my dance's original culture and tradition.
We are definitely not living in the same social context as the Savoy dancers. I have food on my table. I never had to fear for my life. There hasn't been any war in any of the countries I lived in my life for decades. Even though I feel that I am part of a minority, I am not a victim and have never been directly subjected to racism or antisemitism.
But I think there is a sense of social catharsis that still bring us all together in this dance. Why are social dances so popular now ? Why people feel the need to get in physical contact with each other, why people need so much to feel a sense of belonging ? What is it that happen in Herräng every summer ? What is it that gives us the impression that we are going to church every time we enter the Preservation Jazz Hall and hear the bands play ? Is this all related ? I believe so.
This brings me back to my passion for LH and its roots. Battles are interesting because it's another way of challenging the dancers that does not (or less, or differently) depend on your reputation, or your social status in the scene. If Pontus and Frida didn't make it this time, it's because they didn't do as well as last year. The battles are defined by the Right here, Right now. If you don't bring it now, then, too bad. Maybe next time. I will have to think it through a little more, but it might be a more democratic way of judging one's dance, that leave also a chance to unknown dancers who can be brilliant if you just let them dance under the spotlight for a few seconds.
At the street dance comp that I went to, all the prelims were held in a battle format. No all skate. We should think about it.